From my response to Facebook chats etcetera.
DEPENDS on how Americans (or the world) look at "greatness."
<>1898 or late 1890s, when the U.S. defeated the Spanish armada? <>1944, Bretton Woods when the U.S. basically started control of global financial life via the IMF and World Bank? The time the U.S. dollar became the global reserve currency? <>1945, bombing of Hiroshima/Nagasaki and the birth of the atomic bomb? <>1949, NATO's birth and Washington as boss of the global military (especially when the Warsaw Pact dissolved in 1991)?
<>Years before 1975 when the U.S. last had trade surplus and basically ruled manufacturing? Who can tell? As for me, the weakening of U.S. greatness started in 2000 or the 21st century when China began its trade expansionism. Which was also the beginning of the economic rise of the Asian "tigers," Russia cooled out from its apparatchik girth and (trade) diversified via its oil and natural gas mostly, and oil rich Middle East learned Western styled capitalism. And of course the advent of BRICS which balanced G7. And China's 5 banks basically diminished the lending mojo of the IMF.
So essentially because the rest of the world evolved into “little” powers as well albeit economically unlike how the West "won" the world at first, which was via military brinkmanship or outright colonization (sic). And this "weakening" is continually aided by the eerie divide within America. A huge divide (that'd rival the civil war of 1860s) that Howard Zinn predicted before he passed away in 2010. The only way that America could build back better is for its people to show semblance of unity and/or if China closes its door again.
Yet the ignorance persists saying America isn't great anymore because of its sole doing? I don't think so. This: The rest of the world isn't dumb. They know how to achieve greatness as well but not via military arrogance. (Russia is an economic power regardless if it invaded Ukraine or not.) ๐๐ฝ๐
I AM essentially a foreigner in America. I don't see a majority in regards Left/Right. I see a huge divide that I haven't seen in many countries, including in India and China. Whoever won the election. Still the same. Cracked.
Facebook Friend: “My concerns are not based on Left or Right. My concerns are based on Trump’ss platform and rhetoric.”
Platform and rhetoric are political truths. I can say all POTUSes, at the time that I started following Washington politics as a journalist and Leftist activist, had really huge talks. That was imperative though. Grandiose speeches are needed so the allied world continues to obey America and hate the "rogues." Etc etcetera.
So as I semi-retired around 2010 (I think) I stopped watching politicians and presidents talk. In fact, I stopped watching News on TV altogether. But my reading obsession has tripled. Print, internet. Old publications, new stuff. Left. Right. Center. All. US and the world. Meanwhile, I just follow the leadership "walk" and ignore the "talk." And I am not a fan of drama at all. ๐ฝ๐ฝ๐ฝ
[Visual: Tufts. CTTO.]